Transcript of a conversation with Owen Vittanuova, Managing Director at Paradigm, and Lisa Pearson, Founder at Chatter, exploring authentic employer branding, employee advocacy, storytelling, candidate experience and talent retention.
Hosted by:
Owen Vitannouva
Managing Director, Paradigm Creative
Guest speaker:
Lisa Pearson
Founder, Chatter
Introducing Lisa Pearson and Chatter.
Owen:
Hello and welcome to Message Makers. This is where we uncover the knowledge and experience that sits inside the industry. Today we're doing things a little differently. I'm joined by Lisa Pearson from Chatter, an employer brand agency in Leeds whom we've collaborated with on a number of projects. We'll be talking about what an employer brand is, why authenticity is important, and why your recruitment content should match the lived reality in the organisation.
Welcome, Lisa. It's great to have you on the show. We should start by acknowledging that we've collaborated across a number of clients and projects over the years, so we do know each other. It would be great to start with your story. How did you get into the industry? How did your career develop, and what led you to start Chatter? As with a lot of people, it's quite an interesting story that isn't necessarily a straight line.
Lisa:
Absolutely. It's quite apt at the moment, when we've got so many young people out of work. I started on a YTS. My mum saw straight through my exam results, decided I wasn't allowed to do A-levels and told me I had to get a proper job. There was a communication, advertising and marketing foundation course in Leeds, where you were placed in an agency for a couple of days a week.
I applied and got on the course. It was brilliant because a whole group of industry professionals were training young talent. I put myself in that young talent bracket at that point, but not necessarily now. I spent two years working in an agency in Bradford and going to college a few days a week. It was a traditional £30 a week, but I was being trained by PR professionals, people in creative production, and people working in brand within organisations. That was my first step on the marketing communications ladder.
I followed a squiggly path and fell into recruitment a few years later: recruitment marketing, or recruitment as it was. I worked for an agency headquartered in London. We were acquired and, in 2011, everything was moving towards a centralised London hub. We were in the North, and I decided I didn't want to move to London. I love London, but I wanted to live in the North, and the idea of Chatter was born.
Fast forward 15 or 16 years, and we're based in Leeds with 23 people, focusing on helping organisations attract, recruit and engage talent.
Defining an employer brand through experience.
Owen:
You didn't use the term in that story, but employer brand is where you position yourself and Chatter now. For anyone who isn't immersed in that world every day, what does that mean? I think the definition has changed over the last few years and over the time you've been working in it.
Lisa:
I think the definition is still the same. The way employer branding has evolved has changed quite significantly, but ultimately it's how organisations position themselves to be attractive to talent.
Over the last ten years, it's become less inauthentic, less corporate, glossy and vanilla, and much more about storytelling: organisations showing what it's like to work there. With the advent of social media seven or eight years ago, you had to be able to tell a story as an organisation, and that story had to be true. There's been a lot more focus on businesses lifting the lid and providing real insight into what it's like to work for them.
Owen:
We've spoken about how the employer brand that brings somebody into an organisation needs to be authentic. If it doesn't match the reality when they get there, they're unlikely to stay.
Lisa:
Definitely. The impact is huge. Businesses spend so much money trying to attract talent. You should never underestimate how much it costs to bring people into an organisation: the interview process, assessment centres, induction, onboarding, buddy systems and mentoring. If you want to keep those people, you have to give them a clear understanding of what to expect when they join.
Losing people three or six months down the line can have a significant impact on the bottom line and on morale. You don't want a revolving door of talent. That's why the employer brand has been unpicked to include what sits within it: the employee value proposition. What have you got in your locker as a business to offer talent, and what do you expect from them in return?
Connecting recruitment with the employee lifecycle.
Owen:
That's where we've spoken and collaborated a lot. If that's the value proposition, that's how you're communicating it externally. Existing employee voices are really important, but all of that is equally valid for people already working within the organisation. Joining the dots between recruiting people at the front end and their experience within the organisation is really important, right?
Lisa:
Definitely. When we work with organisations, we think about the touchpoints of the EVP and the employer brand. It covers everything from external attraction, and how you look to the market, to the experience you provide when people come into your business, right through to leaving.
We're far more transient than we've ever been. People come into an organisation expecting to be there for a much shorter period. It's not like 30 years ago, when we had this job-for-life mentality. People expect others to move on, and you want them to have a great experience throughout that process.
Internal communications and engagement are about taking people on that journey and giving them a view of what you're doing as a wider employer. That might be attracting new talent, growth, development, transformation, acquiring another business or moving towards an IPO. All of that is important, because people will fill gaps in their knowledge by making things up if they don't hear from the business. There's a real focus on making sure the employer brand goes through the whole employee lifecycle, right through to people leaving.
Owen:
That makes authenticity even more important. If the employer brand you're presenting externally is completely inauthentic and you try to use it with existing employees, they'll see through it. If their lived experience doesn't match what you're presenting, it's not going to cut it. People are pretty savvy.
Lisa:
There are so many more ways for people to determine whether what they're seeing and hearing from a business matches reality. We have Glassdoor, Indeed and word of mouth. Think about ChatGPT now: the ways a potential employee can find out the reality of an organisation are front and centre. It's very easy to discover what a business is really like.
You want employees to speak openly and freely, advocate for your brand and tell people what it's really like to work there. If you're a nine-to-five person and a business has much higher expectations, that won't work for you. If you like a quiet environment where you can get your head down, but the business is noisy and there's a lot going on, understanding that is important.
Retaining talent through the Great Stay.
Owen:
When we mapped this conversation out a couple of weeks ago, you touched on how different the employment market feels from three or four years ago, and the implications for employer branding. You mentioned AI's impact on recruitment, skills shortages alongside higher unemployment, and terms I hadn't heard before: resenteeism and the Great Stay. What are you seeing that people in communications roles might not be aware of, or might not have broken down in that way?
Lisa:
The market right now is very strange. COVID was crap; it was a tough time for everybody. Afterwards, we had a real boom in the talent market. People were paying way over the odds for talent and scrambling to get the best people. Salaries were inflated, and there was a lot of movement.
Fast forward to now, and we've got the highest level of youth unemployment for I don't know how many years. It's high: 16% to 17% of 18-to-24-year-olds are out of work. You've got people coming off graduate schemes and apprenticeships, and college leavers who literally cannot get a job. Then there are people we call NEETs: not in education, employment or training. There's a big population there.
You've also got people within organisations where the cost of living has really increased, and opportunities to move between businesses are few and far between. People are staying, but not necessarily because they have a desire to be within that organisation, although I'm sure some do. They're staying because there isn't that much out there. They're hanging on until there are more opportunities.
Couple that with a whole group of young talent who actively want jobs, but there's nothing for them, and it's a really strange time. At some point, people will move. The market will open up, the jobs market will change significantly, and some of the great people you've got may just be staying to see what's around the corner.
How do you keep them? How do you give them the career opportunities, development and things they would otherwise look for externally, right now within your business? There's a lot more focus on keeping great talent, so when the jobs market changes, those people stay rather than migrate to the next big thing.
Andy Burnham is very focused on social mobility and making sure people have opportunities, particularly young talent coming into the marketplace. Long may it continue. Let's see whether this starts opening opportunities for young people and gives us more mobility across the UK employment market.
Equipping employees to advocate for the business.
Owen:
Everything goes in cycles. At the moment, there isn't much movement, so you want internal communications and the employee experience to be as good as possible. You want to hang on to great people when things do move. That's where we've worked together a lot: creating content to present the employer brand, then working on projects to help employees become advocates of the business.
Lisa:
Your people are your greatest advocates if they're treated and managed well, understand what they're talking about and are equipped to talk confidently. Think about the work we've done with O2 around the network and experience. It's invaluable for existing employees to understand the business they work for and how to talk about it, whether they're down the pub or talking to friends about what they do, why they do it and why they work there. There's an absolute overlap between the two.
Owen:
For somebody in a different organisation, perhaps without the same budgets, the takeaway is to make sure people understand the customer experience, whatever part of the business they work in. They should understand customers' frustrations, the good experiences they're having and what the organisation is doing about it. That goes back to advocacy, whether you're talking about what it's like to work there or what your company does. Equipping employees to talk confidently about their business is massively important.
Lisa:
For lots of reasons, depending on where you are as a business and the journey you're taking people on, there are things you can't talk about. There is commercially sensitive information that businesses can't give their people. But as an employee, you feel more confident if you're equipped with information that helps you understand the next six, 12, 18 or 24 months.
Being clear about the organisation's vision, mission and values, the role I play and the behaviours expected of people is exceptionally important. If you're going through organisational change, or communicating something that connects what you do with your consumers, whether you're B2B or B2C, that helps people connect with the bottom line and those using your services. It explains why you're here every day doing your job.
Never underestimate that. You can communicate it in an engaging way that makes people more likely to understand it and talk about it to others.
Telling stories employees can recognise themselves in.
Owen:
One topic we touched on when planning this was storytelling. How do you tell authentic stories about an organisation and its individuals? How do you make that accessible and give people the confidence to see themselves in a role, and in a journey through the organisation?
Lisa:
Storytelling isn't new. It's probably been in our space for 12 or 13 years. With so much focus on social media and social content, and people wanting snapshots of information, real people telling real stories about real things can never be underestimated. I keep using the word authentic, even though it's completely overused.
People need to digest it in multiple ways, whether that's podcasts, rich media or social content. Video is exceptionally important in bringing it to life, because once you see yourself in somebody else, you're more likely to take the leap and apply for a role, or recognise that it isn't for you.
Within a business, for training and development, there are lots of ways to deliver core information in a more authentic, storytelling way that engages people throughout their lifecycle. It's here to stay. There will be more focus on user-generated content: it can be polished, but not overly polished.
Owen:
In 20 years working in video production and events, I've seen people wanting more content, more quickly, and the rise of user-generated content and influencers. When people say influencers, they think of external people selling a product, but it can just as easily be somebody within an organisation who becomes its voice.
All those types of content have a place. It's about being intentional in how you use them. You can create user-generated, behind-the-scenes content around a glossy production. Years ago, we'd shoot behind-the-scenes content of a TV advert being made. The advert was a huge production, and filming behind the scenes would be interesting. But it would be even more interesting to take an employee from that organisation and give them that experience.
The internal story is then about Sally, who doesn't get to do that day to day, and her experience, rather than just a glossy TV production. It's an amazing story for her to tell her peers and post on LinkedIn. All the different types of content have a place. It's about being intentional and joining the dots.
Adapting content for different audiences and channels.
We both tend to work with fairly large organisations with lots of departments and touchpoints. Sometimes what we bring is joining the dots: if we're making something for you, have you thought about using it here, here and here? Creating versions and different assets is relatively easy and gets far more value from what you're making. Are people starting to think more holistically about the stories they're telling?
Lisa:
The use cases and places where content appears are so different. TikTok is hugely different from Instagram and Facebook. Everybody is trying to gather lots of content in a relatively short time and recut it for different audience groups.
You can still have a hero video or corporate view of what it's like to work within a business, peppered with stories from across the organisation. Those might be anything from ten-second shots to long-form content or podcasts. Getting as much bang for your buck as possible is important, but so is looking at a project or shoot schedule and determining how it needs to work on different levels for different people.
Going back to employer brand and the EVP, what appeals to a procurement manager will be very different from what appeals to somebody in software development or HR. A big part of what we do, and where you have to nuance communications, is making sure you're appealing to different people and showing them what's important to them.
Owen:
It's not once and done any more. There are so many applications that we have to look at this work more holistically.
Building an EVP from evidence and insight.
For somebody watching or listening who knows their organisation needs to work on its employer brand, where do you start? Obviously, one way is to contact you at Chatter. But if they're trying to make small improvements, are there any takeaways or little things that can make a big difference?
Lisa:
Most large organisations talk to employees regularly through pulse surveys and annual employee surveys, so they've got lots of rich data to start with. The key to understanding and building an employer brand is to start with your employee value proposition. What have you got right now? How does it stack up for the different audiences you're trying to reach? How do people feel about it, and how do you package it to make sense externally?
Start by understanding what you've got. If you don't fully understand it, you can do gap analysis: talk to people, run listening groups or do external research. It's good to look beyond yourself and consider how you compare with the competition. If you're losing people to certain businesses, or admire how other organisations manage their people, it's worth looking at what you could bring into your own business.
Don't be insular; look externally too. Do research, perhaps qualitative or quantitative, to get some data. Speak to leaders and get a view from the top. Where are you going? How will you get there? What's the vision for the future? Then understand how your people feel about it.
Those insights should give you a platform to develop your employee value proposition. In turn, that leads to what it looks and feels like, how it shows up to talent, and the experience you give people. There are lots of steps, but it's relatively straightforward: how do you appeal to the head and heart of people who want to work in the business or stay in the organisation?
Then wrap it in something easily digestible and visible across all your touchpoints: the careers website, external advertising, and the way you bring it to life. You need consistency and to join the dots, so when people join, what they see inside matches what they've seen externally.
How candidate experience affects the consumer brand.
Owen:
When we spoke before, you had a good example of unintended consequences, particularly in volume recruitment. If the employer brand is inauthentic and people have a poor recruitment experience, they may stop shopping at that business, even if they don't get the job. It's about getting all those things right.
Lisa:
Definitely. We work with some really large businesses and big volume recruiters: Asda, Morrisons and ITV. When your consumer brand is such an important part of what you do, it's vital to give people a good experience as potential employees, irrespective of where they land or leave the process. That's tough when some businesses receive thousands of applications almost daily.
There are little things you can do, such as getting back to people on time. Automation helps massively, but you can't take away the human touch. You want people to have a great experience, even if they don't get the job, because ultimately they're your shoppers and consumers.
When I've had a poor experience as a consumer, I've stopped using or shopping with that business. The same happens in the employer space. Candidates can get fed up with a recruitment process and decide not to buy from a business, or eat or drink in a bar or restaurant, because of that experience. It's important for B2B businesses too, but for business-to-consumer organisations it's front and centre, and can have a big impact on their customer base.
Finding the right voice for employee audiences.
Owen:
Another example that resonated was a travel business. The temptation is to think, 'We've got a brand and we talk to our customers, so we'll talk to employees in the same way.' But the way that business spoke to customers was very different from how it needed to speak to potential recruits. Why is that difference between the two voices important?
Lisa:
You're selling something very different. If you sell a holiday, you're selling an experience, but it's a thing. Joining a business is an emotional decision, and staying is an emotional decision. There are so many things at play. You're not buying or selling a chocolate bar, or even a car, which is still a big purchase.
In internal communications and employer branding, we need people to connect with a business on a human level. They're making a decision rationally and emotionally, thinking about what's good for their head and heart. That's often very different from the consumer landscape.
The same principles apply: it needs to look good, have the right tone of voice and provide a good experience. But you're selling two very different things. We want to offer something real and authentic, and give people a great experience, because these are people's lives. We can't be frivolous with that. We're not stacking it high and selling it cheap.
Owen:
We worked on a project years ago where the outward-facing brand was quite experimental. A large part of the employee audience were engineers who'd been there for years. Their perception was that the external brand was a bit too 'jazz hands'; they didn't relate to it.
That informed everything we did going forward. The two had to join somewhere in the middle, but we intentionally used the brand very differently externally and internally because the audiences had different expectations and perceptions. A couple of quick-fire questions: what's been your favourite project, and why?
Rethinking recruitment for a different retail experience.
Lisa:
I've not rehearsed this one or thought about it much. I've worked on some amazing projects, but one stands out: O2, a fair few years ago, before Virgin Media and O2 became VMO2.
They were looking at their retail customer proposition and wanted to create two test shops. They were called "Stores of the Future". You might remember this, Owen. They ripped up the rulebook. We helped create an experience from external attraction onwards, rewriting all the job descriptions.
We focused on people with soft skills and lots of personality, rather than technical knowledge about phones or selling accessories. It was about the experience. We even looked at hiring actors. It was a really cool piece of work.
The whole experience was end to end. We had a pop-up store in Green Lane, London and a pop-up trailer at the Etihad in Manchester. For a week we ran assessment centres. We did the external attraction and rewrote job descriptions because we wanted a very different kind of person to join O2.
They didn't roll it out across their full network, but they took a lot of learning from it, including providing more of an experience when people came into a shop so they would buy more consumables. People could have a coffee, sit down and work. It was more Apple Genius than a traditional mobile phone shop where you expect somebody to pounce as soon as you walk through the door. It had an impact, and they learned a lot.
The experience was brilliant because we ripped up the rulebook and did everything from start to finish.
Owen:
The whole retail experience is now more of a destination, rather than things stacked on a shelf. People can order online, so if they're going to the high street, they need an experience and an interaction.
Lisa:
Definitely. There are lots of other projects, too many to think about. I've got a great team, brilliant clients, and we're doing some amazing work. We did some brilliant work for the KFC UK team, including some quite game-changing work in that space. There's lots to be excited about for the future.
Owen:
That's it for this episode of Message Makers. Thanks again to Lisa for joining me and sharing her insight. Don't forget to subscribe on your platform of choice. If you've got any questions or suggestions for topics to cover, get in touch.
